| Selection | Team | Player | Position |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Rapid City Mudhens | Cody Bellinger | 1b |
| 2 | Syracuse Nox | Rafael Devers | 3b |
| 3 | Central Valley Farmworkers Union | Rhys Hoskins | lf |
| 4 | Augusta Green Jackets | Yoan Moncada | 2b |
| 5 | Harrison Knights | Matt Chapman | 3b |
| 6 | Moose Pond Bull Moose | Ozzie Albies | 2b |
| 7 | Baldwin Bombers | Luis Castillo | sp |
| 8 | Bellmore Shih Tzus | Amed Rosario | ss |
| 9 | Fog City Liberals | Paul DeJong | ss |
| 10 | Augusta Green Jackets | Francis Martes | mr |
| 11 | Montreal Royals | J.P. Crawford | 3b |
| 12 | Arrowhead Griffins | Manuel Margot | cf |
| 13 | New York Highlanders | Bradley Zimmer | cf |
| 14 | Atlantic City High Rollers | Matt Olson | 1b |
| 15 | Baldwin Bombers | Lucas Giolito | sp |
| 16 | Moose Pond Bull Moose | Luiz Gohara | sp |
| 17 | Atlantic City High Rollers | Ian Happ | cf |
| 18 | Portsmouth Harbor Seals | Jordan Montgomery | sp |
| 19 | Portsmouth Harbor Seals | German Marquez | sp |
| 20 | Bellmore Shih Tzus | Jacob Faria | sp |
| 21 | Moose Pond Bull Moose | Sean Newcomb | sp |
| 22 | Syracuse Nox | Antonio Senzatela | sp |
| 23 | Baldwin Bombers | Franklin Barreto | ss |
| 24 | Portsmouth Harbor Seals | Trey Mancini | lf |
| Selection | Team | Player | Position |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Harrison Knights | Austin Barnes | c |
| 2 | Baldwin Bombers | Carson Kelly | c |
| 3 | Arrowhead Griffins | Dinelson Lamet | sp |
| 4 | Portsmouth Harbor Seals | Derek Fisher | lf |
| 5 | Central Valley Farmworkers Union | Trevor Williams | sp |
| 6 | New York Highlanders | Ben Gamel | lf |
| 7 | Rapid City Mudhens | Josh Hader | mr |
| 8 | Bellmore Shih Tzus | Tyler Glasnow | sp |
| 9 | Fog City Liberals | Jake Junis | sp |
| 10 | Bellmore Shih Tzus | Nick Williams | rf |
| 11 | Harrison Knights | Jesse Winker | rf |
| 12 | Arrowhead Griffins | Hunter Renfroe | rf |
| 13 | Moose Pond Bull Moose | Yandy Diaz | 3b |
| 14 | Moose Pond Bull Moose | Clint Frazier | lf |
| 15 | West Berkeley Barbecue | Jeimer Candelario | 3b |
| 16 | Central Valley Farmworkers Union | Kyle Freeland | sp |
| 17 | Harrison Knights | Nick Pivetta | sp |
| 18 | New York Highlanders | Brent Suter | sp |
| 19 | Harrison Knights | Sal Romano | sp |
| 20 | Syracuse Nox | Parker Bridwell | sp |
| 21 | Baldwin Bombers | Jorge Alfaro | c |
| 22 | Portsmouth Harbor Seals | Max Fried | mr |
| 23 | Moose Pond Bull Moose | Raimel Tapia | rf |
| 24 | Bellmore Shih Tzus | Wilmer Difo | ss |
| Selection | Team | Player | Position |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | New York Highlanders | Ty Blach | sp |
| 2 | Fog City Liberals | Brian Anderson | 3b |
| 3 | Rapid City Mudhens | Anthony Banda | sp |
| 4 | Rapid City Mudhens | Paul Blackburn | sp |
| 5 | Syracuse Nox | Jorge Bonifacio | rf |
| 6 | Moose Pond Bull Moose | Brett Phillips | cf |
| 7 | Augusta Green Jackets | Amir Garrett | sp |
| 8 | Syracuse Nox | Lucas Sims | sp |
| 9 | Fog City Liberals | Emilio Pagan | mr |
| 10 | Portsmouth Harbor Seals | Boog Powell | cf |
| 11 | Montreal Royals | Nicky Delmonico | lf |
| 12 | Arrowhead Griffins | Christian Arroyo | 3b |
| 13 | New York Highlanders | Kyle Crick | mr |
| 14 | Fog City Liberals | Trevor Hildenberger | mr |
| 15 | Harrison Knights | Brandon Woodruff | sp |
| 16 | Bellmore Shih Tzus | Dominic Smith | 1b |
| 17 | Augusta Green Jackets | Daniel Gossett | sp |
| 18 | Fog City Liberals | Sam Tuivailala | mr |
| 19 | Rapid City Mudhens | A.J. Minter | mr |
| 20 | Baldwin Bombers | Allen Cordoba | lf |
| 21 | Mentone Beach Maulers | Chad Pinder | rf |
| 22 | Moose Pond Bull Moose | Adalberto Mejia | sp |
| 23 | Portsmouth Harbor Seals | Jose Martinez | 1b |
| 24 | Rapid City Mudhens | Ben Lively | sp |
| Selection | Team | Player | Position |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Atlantic City High Rollers | Jesus Aguilar | 1b |
| 2 | Atlantic City High Rollers | Frankie Montas | mr |
| 3 | Syracuse Nox | Johan Camargo | 3b |
| 4 | Harrison Knights | Chris Stratton | sp |
| 5 | New York Highlanders | Sam Travis | 1b |
| 6 | Rapid City Mudhens | Pat Valaika | ss |
| 7 | Mentone Beach Maulers | Brian Goodwin | cf |
| 8 | Syracuse Nox | Paul Sewald | mr |
| 9 | Rapid City Mudhens | Austin Maddox | mr |
| 10 | Syracuse Nox | Keynan Middleton | mr |
| 11 | Fog City Liberals | John Brebbia | mr |
| 12 | Arrowhead Griffins | Richard Urena | ss |
| 13 | Augusta Green Jackets | Harrison Bader | cf |
| 14 | Grand Forks Winter Wheats | Zack Granite | cf |
| 15 | West Berkeley Barbecue | Dillon Peters | sp |
| 16 | Syracuse Nox | Jarlin Garcia | mr |
| 17 | Syracuse Nox | Austin Slater | lf |
| 18 | Rapid City Mudhens | Jose Alvarado | mr |
| 19 | Augusta Green Jackets | Deven Marrero | 3b |
| 20 | Baldwin Bombers | Carlos Asuaje | 2b |
| 21 | Portsmouth Harbor Seals | Drew Steckenrider | mr |
| 22 | West Berkeley Barbecue | Chris Flexen | sp |
| 23 | Fog City Liberals | Wandy Peralta | mr |
| 24 | Augusta Green Jackets | Tony Zych | mr |