| Selection | Team | Player | Position |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Schenectady Massacre | Mike Trout | rf |
| 2 | Milwaukee Beers | Brett Lawrie | 3b |
| 3 | New York Jaywalkers | Dustin Ackley | 2b |
| 4 | Staten Island Ferries | Michael Pineda | sp |
| 5 | New York Jaywalkers | Eric Hosmer | 1b |
| 6 | Schenectady Massacre | Jesus Montero | dh |
| 7 | Ann Arbor Airmax | Desmond Jennings | lf |
| 8 | Staten Island Ferries | Mike Moustakas | 3b |
| 9 | Toronto Storm | Freddie Freeman | 1b |
| 10 | New York Jaywalkers | Lonnie Chisenhall | 3b |
| 11 | New York Jaywalkers | Devin Mesoraco | c |
| 12 | Schenectady Massacre | Domonic Brown | rf |
| 13 | Schaumburg Sparrows | Aroldis Chapman | mr |
| 14 | Mentone Beach Maulers | Brandon Beachy | sp |
| 15 | Braidwood Blast | Jason Kipnis | 2b |
| 16 | Baldwin Bombers | Brandon Belt | lf |
| 17 | Schenectady Massacre | Anthony Rizzo | 1b |
| 18 | Rapid City Mudhens | J.P. Arencibia | c |
| 19 | Staten Island Ferries | Dee Gordon | ss |
| 20 | Camden Evolution | Yonder Alonso | lf |
| 21 | Atlantic City High Rollers | Jemile Weeks | 2b |
| 22 | Arrowhead Griffins | Josh Collmenter | sp |
| 23 | Mentone Beach Maulers | Cory Luebke | mr |
| 24 | Mentone Beach Maulers | Vance Worley | sp |
| Selection | Team | Player | Position |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Milwaukee Beers | Paul Goldschmidt | 1b |
| 2 | Staten Island Ferries | Salvador Perez | c |
| 3 | Baldwin Bombers | Trayvon Robinson | lf |
| 4 | Schenectady Massacre | Hank Conger | c |
| 5 | Milwaukee Beers | Zachary Britton | sp |
| 6 | Mentone Beach Maulers | Henderson Alvarez | sp |
| 7 | Ann Arbor Airmax | Jose Altuve | 2b |
| 8 | Baldwin Bombers | J.D. Martinez | lf |
| 9 | Toronto Storm | Jerry Sands | lf |
| 10 | Ann Arbor Airmax | Mark Trumbo | 1b |
| 11 | Syracuse Comets | Randall Delgado | sp |
| 12 | Baldwin Bombers | Wilin Rosario | c |
| 13 | Schaumburg Sparrows | Kyle Drabek | sp |
| 14 | Schenectady Massacre | Josh Reddick | rf |
| 15 | Braidwood Blast | Ben Revere | cf |
| 16 | Arrowhead Griffins | John Mayberry | cf |
| 17 | Schenectady Massacre | Mike Carp | 1b |
| 18 | New York Jaywalkers | Danny Duffy | sp |
| 19 | Schenectady Massacre | Eric Thames | lf |
| 20 | Schenectady Massacre | Tsuyoshi Nishioka | ss |
| 21 | Montreal Royals | Johnny Giavotella | 2b |
| 22 | Baldwin Bombers | Alex Cobb | sp |
| 23 | Ann Arbor Airmax | Aaron Crow | mr |
| 24 | Huntington Headshrinkers | Arodys Vizcaino | mr |
| Selection | Team | Player | Position |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Milwaukee Beers | Guillermo Moscoso | sp |
| 2 | Staten Island Ferries | Rubby De La Rosa | sp |
| 3 | Staten Island Ferries | Logan Forsythe | 3b |
| 4 | Montreal Royals | Jordan Lyles | sp |
| 5 | Mentone Beach Maulers | Philip Humber | sp |
| 6 | Arrowhead Griffins | Hector Noesi | mr |
| 7 | Ann Arbor Airmax | Javy Guerra | cl |
| 8 | Mentone Beach Maulers | Vinnie Pestano | mr |
| 9 | Mentone Beach Maulers | David Cooper | 1b |
| 10 | Milwaukee Beers | Eduardo Nunez | ss |
| 11 | Syracuse Comets | Nathan Eovaldi | sp |
| 12 | Mentone Beach Maulers | Chris Parmelee | 1b |
| 13 | Schaumburg Sparrows | Alex White | sp |
| 14 | Atlantic City High Rollers | Al Alburquerque | mr |
| 15 | Braidwood Blast | Tyler Flowers | c |
| 16 | Baldwin Bombers | Eric Surkamp | sp |
| 17 | Fog City Liberals | Juan Nicasio | sp |
| 18 | Rapid City Mudhens | Todd Frazier | 3b |
| 19 | Ann Arbor Airmax | Lance Lynn | mr |
| 20 | Huntington Headshrinkers | Kyle Seager | 3b |
| 21 | Mentone Beach Maulers | Brent Morel | 3b |
| 22 | Arrowhead Griffins | Jesus Guzman | 1b |
| 23 | Mentone Beach Maulers | Steve Cishek | mr |
| 24 | Baldwin Bombers | Chris Nelson | 2b |
| Selection | Team | Player | Position |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Staten Island Ferries | Rex Brothers | mr |
| 2 | Atlantic City High Rollers | Eduardo Sanchez | mr |
| 3 | Milwaukee Beers | Tom Milone | sp |
| 4 | Ann Arbor Airmax | Joel Carreno | mr |
| 5 | Atlantic City High Rollers | Jimmy Paredes | 3b |
| 6 | Fog City Liberals | Josh Lindblom | mr |
| 7 | Brooklyn Brawlers | Tim Collins | mr |
| 8 | Mentone Beach Maulers | Juan Francisco | 3b |
| 9 | Toronto Storm | Trevor Plouffe | ss |
| 10 | Syracuse Comets | Alex Presley | lf |
| 11 | Ann Arbor Airmax | Michael Stutes | mr |
| 12 | Mentone Beach Maulers | David Carpenter | mr |
| 13 | Schaumburg Sparrows | Jake McGee | mr |
| 14 | Arrowhead Griffins | Everett Teaford | mr |
| 15 | Braidwood Blast | Blake Beavan | sp |
| 16 | Arrowhead Griffins | Justin Turner | 2b |
| 17 | Charlotte Bashers | Collin Cowgill | lf |
| 18 | Rapid City Mudhens | Andy Dirks | lf |
| 19 | Atlantic City High Rollers | Daniel Descalso | 3b |
| 20 | Camden Evolution | Louis Coleman | mr |
| 21 | Schenectady Massacre | Chase d'Arnaud | ss |
| 22 | Huntington Headshrinkers | Bryan Petersen | cf |
| 23 | Mentone Beach Maulers | Anthony Bass | mr |
| 24 | Schenectady Massacre | Jason Pridie | cf |