| Selection | Team | Player | Position |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Starved Rock Magi | Jose Fernandez | sp |
| 2 | Atlantic City High Rollers | Gerrit Cole | sp |
| 3 | Nevada Owls | Wil Myers | rf |
| 4 | Fog City Liberals | Shelby Miller | sp |
| 5 | Fog City Liberals | Yasiel Puig | rf |
| 6 | Long Beach Slammers | Jurickson Profar | 2b |
| 7 | Astoria Amazins | Zack Wheeler | sp |
| 8 | Augusta Green Jackets | Michael Wacha | sp |
| 9 | Long Beach Slammers | Julio Teheran | sp |
| 10 | Fog City Liberals | Danny Salazar | sp |
| 11 | Atlantic City High Rollers | Christian Yelich | lf |
| 12 | Portsmouth Harbor Seals | Nolan Arenado | 3b |
| 13 | Braidwood Blast | Avisail Garcia | rf |
| 14 | Starved Rock Magi | Jedd Gyorko | 2b |
| 15 | Milwaukee Beers | Sonny Gray | sp |
| 16 | Rapid City Mudhens | Tony Cingrani | sp |
| 17 | Grand Forks Winter Wheats | Anthony Rendon | 2b |
| 18 | Arrowhead Griffins | Hyun-Jin Ryu | sp |
| 19 | Long Beach Slammers | Kevin Gausman | mr |
| 20 | Milwaukee Beers | Mike Zunino | c |
| 21 | Fog City Liberals | Khris Davis | lf |
| 22 | Oakland Agitators | Jackie Bradley | cf |
| 23 | Brooklyn Brawlers | Leonys Martin | cf |
| 24 | Staten Island Ferries | Carlos Martinez | mr |
| Selection | Team | Player | Position |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Fog City Liberals | Kole Calhoun | rf |
| 2 | Milwaukee Beers | Jake Odorizzi | sp |
| 3 | Nevada Owls | Brad Miller | ss |
| 4 | Fog City Liberals | Alex Wood | mr |
| 5 | Fog City Liberals | Evan Gattis | c |
| 6 | Portsmouth Harbor Seals | Oswaldo Arcia | lf |
| 7 | Astoria Amazins | Travis d'Arnaud | c |
| 8 | Augusta Green Jackets | Scooter Gennett | 2b |
| 9 | Long Beach Slammers | Nick Franklin | 2b |
| 10 | Montreal Royals | Josmil Pinto | c |
| 11 | Milwaukee Beers | Jake Marisnick | cf |
| 12 | Starved Rock Magi | Jarred Cosart | sp |
| 13 | Braidwood Blast | Matt Davidson | 3b |
| 14 | Nevada Owls | Cody Asche | 3b |
| 15 | Oakland Agitators | Marcell Ozuna | rf |
| 16 | Rapid City Mudhens | Didi Gregorius | ss |
| 17 | Grand Forks Winter Wheats | Tony Sanchez | c |
| 18 | Arrowhead Griffins | Aaron Hicks | cf |
| 19 | Fog City Liberals | Jonathan Villar | ss |
| 20 | Portsmouth Harbor Seals | Kyle Gibson | sp |
| 21 | Baldwin Bombers | Brett Oberholtzer | sp |
| 22 | Nevada Owls | Robbie Erlin | sp |
| 23 | Portsmouth Harbor Seals | Allen Webster | sp |
| 24 | Augusta Green Jackets | Darin Ruf | 1b |
| Selection | Team | Player | Position |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Nevada Owls | Paco Rodriguez | mr |
| 2 | Atlantic City High Rollers | Robbie Grossman | lf |
| 3 | Portsmouth Harbor Seals | Tanner Roark | mr |
| 4 | Baldwin Bombers | Kevin Siegrist | mr |
| 5 | Baldwin Bombers | Junior Lake | lf |
| 6 | Brooklyn Brawlers | Brandon Maurer | sp |
| 7 | Astoria Amazins | Tyler Thornburg | mr |
| 8 | Atlantic City High Rollers | Juan Lagares | cf |
| 9 | Long Beach Slammers | Erik Johnson | sp |
| 10 | Mentone Beach Maulers | Scott Van Slyke | lf |
| 11 | Oakland Agitators | Burch Smith | sp |
| 12 | Atlantic City High Rollers | Johnny Hellweg | sp |
| 13 | Braidwood Blast | Wilmer Flores | 3b |
| 14 | Nevada Owls | Jordy Mercer | ss |
| 15 | Nevada Owls | Brad Peacock | sp |
| 16 | Rapid City Mudhens | Caleb Thielbar | mr |
| 17 | Oakland Agitators | Chad Bettis | sp |
| 18 | Long Beach Slammers | Taylor Jordan | sp |
| 19 | Atlantic City High Rollers | Corey Dickerson | lf |
| 20 | Baldwin Bombers | L.J. Hoes | rf |
| 21 | Atlantic City High Rollers | Alexander Torres | mr |
| 22 | Baldwin Bombers | A.J. Ramos | mr |
| 23 | Long Beach Slammers | Danny Farquhar | cl |
| 24 | Montreal Royals | Derek Dietrich | 2b |
| Selection | Team | Player | Position |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | New York Jaywalkers | Justin Wilson | mr |
| 2 | Atlantic City High Rollers | Andre Rienzo | sp |
| 3 | Baldwin Bombers | Bruce Rondon | mr |
| 4 | Baldwin Bombers | Ryan Goins | 2b |
| 5 | Baldwin Bombers | Tommy Medica | 1b |
| 6 | Long Beach Slammers | Vic Black | mr |
| 7 | Astoria Amazins | Conor Gillaspie | 3b |
| 8 | Atlantic City High Rollers | Brandon Workman | mr |
| 9 | Long Beach Slammers | David Lough | rf |
| 10 | Arrowhead Griffins | Ed Lucas | 3b |
| 11 | Ann Arbor Airmax | Ryan Pressly | mr |
| 12 | Portsmouth Harbor Seals | Justin Grimm | sp |
| 13 | Braidwood Blast | Chris Withrow | mr |
| 14 | Ann Arbor Airmax | Nate Freiman | 1b |
| 15 | Arrowhead Griffins | Yoervis Medina | mr |
| 16 | Rapid City Mudhens | Jonathan Pettibone | sp |
| 17 | Portsmouth Harbor Seals | Dan Otero | mr |
| 18 | Arrowhead Griffins | Caleb Gindl | lf |
| 19 | Portsmouth Harbor Seals | Josh Satin | 1b |
| 20 | Grand Forks Winter Wheats | Adam Warren | mr |
| 21 | Baldwin Bombers | Cesar Hernandez | cf |
| 22 | Nevada Owls | Grant Green | 2b |
| 23 | Milwaukee Beers | Nick Tepesch | sp |
| 24 | Mentone Beach Maulers | Josh Phegley | c |